Screen

  • Print
  • Small FontsDefault FontsLarge Fonts

Oscar bait: Revisiting our critics’ takes on this year’s Best Picture nominees

The Academy Awards air February 24 at 5:30 p.m. on ABC. Before the golden men get passed around, we revisit our critics’ takes on this year’s Best Picture nominees.

    • Amour

      Josh Bell: Three stars

      Mike D’Angelo: Four stars

      From our review: “Amour is in some ways more humane and compassionate than [writer-director Michael] Haneke’s previous work, but it retains the cold, detached style of his more provocative films, framing its simple domestic story almost like a clinical study of human frailty.” —JB

      See it: At Regal Cinemas Village Square.

    • Argo

      Josh Bell: Four stars

      Mike D’Angelo: Three and a half stars

      From our review: “It’s the kind of movie that wins Oscars, sure, but it’s also consistently entertaining and socially conscious without being heavy-handed.” —JB

      See it: In theaters and on DVD.

    • Beasts of the Southern Wild

      Josh Bell: Two and a half stars

      Mike D’Angelo: Three and a half stars

      From our review: “Just because something is different doesn’t make it successful, and all of the unique elements here never add up to a cohesive or satisfying whole.” —JB

      See it: At Regal Cinemas Village Square and on DVD.

    • Django Unchained

      Josh Bell: Three and a half stars

      Mike D’Angelo: Three and a half stars

      From our review: “Django is undoubtedly one of the most creative and striking movies of 2012, but it’s also one of the most exhausting.” —JB

      See it: In theaters.

    • Les Misérables

      Josh Bell: Two and a half stars

      Mike D’Angelo: Two and a half stars

      From our review: “There’s bombast a-plenty in the film’s gargantuan sets and the camera’s CGI swooping, but [director Tom] Hooper can’t establish a simple cinematic rhythm to save his life.” —MD

      See it: In theaters.

    • Life of Pi

      Josh Bell: Two and a half stars

      Mike D’Angelo: Three stars

      From our review: “The story lacks emotional engagement, especially whenever [director Ang] Lee returns to the clumsy framing sequence, and the fanciful tone is eventually at odds with the seriousness of Pi’s circumstances.” —JB

      See it: At Regal Cinemas Village Square.

    • Lincoln

      Josh Bell: Three and a half stars

      Mike D’Angelo: Two and a half stars

      From our review: “Even if Lincoln isn’t quite the mesmerizing figure the movie would like him to be, he’s still an essential part of this entertaining and engrossing story.” —JB

      See it: In theaters.

    • Silver Linings Playbook

      Josh Bell: Four stars

      Mike D’Angelo: Two and a half stars

      From our review: “Nothing rings true, least of all the crowd-pleasing notion that manic depression magically vanishes if you find the right partner.” —MD

      See it: In theaters.

    • Zero Dark Thirty

      Josh Bell: Four stars

      Mike D’Angelo: Three and a half stars

      From our review: “The film is ... unemphatically gripping—a data-driven procedural that acknowledges the needle-in-a-haystack nature of intelligence work.” —MD

      See it: In theaters.

    Print This

    Discussion:

    In an effort to increase the dialogue on our stories, we will be requiring Facebook accounts to leave comments on lasvegasweekly.com stories. We believe that Weekly readers are likely to have Facebook accounts already and more apt to comment on this site with that account rather than have to create an account with us. If, however, you do not have a Facebook account, click here to sign up for one. If you have questions, comments or concerns about this new commenting policy, please let us know.

    For any other questions related to commenting on Weekly stories, please read our full policy.

    Facebook Activity